Orangeville General Insurance Brokers Call : 519.942.2422

Coffey Brothers Insurance Brokers Ltd. is an established local general insurance brokerage offering quality insurance products delivered through a knowledgeable and friendly staff.”


Coffey Brothers concentrates on building relationships with people, “Our service is relationship driven, we value our clients!”  says Joe Coffey.  Customer retention and referrals are a mainstay of our business.  “We are now serving multi-generational clients; the Parents use us and now the children do as well…not only are they clients but they become friends.

Coffey Brothers Insurance is open Saturday mornings to service commuting clients and even make house calls.


“Top-notch service.   From long time customer.”
Sam Crimi

Our History

Coffey Brothers Insurance Brokers Ltd. was started in the summer of 1988 by then 23 year old twin brothers Jim and Joe Coffey.  Having been raised in the Arthur area, the brothers felt a larger trading center was key to their long term success and settled in Orangeville.  Jim has since moved on from the business and today the brokerage is operated by Joe and his capable staff.


The brokerage began as a new business startup without existing clients.  Straight forward insurance advice and dependable customer service has allowed Coffey Brothers Insurance Brokers Ltd. to add new customers and grow the business in each of its almost 30 years of operation.  Many of those early year new customers remain today forming our loyal long term client base.  Along with steady new client growth, Coffey Brothers was fortunate to add 2 local books of business over the years.  In 1996 the Madill Insurance Agency from Orangeville was added and more recently in 2013, Joe and his staff welcomed the clients of Gordon McArthur Insurance from Hillsburg to the office.